Best Pet Insurance in Colorado for 2026

Why You Should Trust Us: What to Know About Our Review Process
We receive compensation from partner links in this post, but payment does not limit the products we test or review. We include both partner and non-partner offers in our recommendations to help our readers find the best products and services. All editorial opinions are our own, and we transparently disclose all of our paid partnerships in our Advertiser Disclosure.

Colorado is a paradise for outdoor-loving pet owners, with world-class hiking, camping, and adventure around every corner. The Centennial State’s active lifestyle means dogs are constant companions on trails, peaks, and ski slopes. But Colorado’s dramatic landscape comes with unique challenges. The state’s high altitude affects pets just as it affects humans. Mountain lions and black bears are real concerns in foothill communities. Colorado tick fever is a disease found almost nowhere else. And Denver’s explosive growth has sharply increased veterinary costs. Whether you’re summiting a fourteener with your dog, exploring Rocky Mountain National Park, or enjoying Denver’s dog-friendly breweries, pet insurance is essential for Colorado pet parents.

We reviewed and ranked 20 of the largest and most popular pet insurance companies to help Colorado pet owners find the right coverage. Here’s our list of the best pet insurance companies for Colorado residents in 2026.

Best Pet Insurance in Colorado Overview

RateChaser's picks for the best pet insurance in Colorado.
Pet Insurance CompanyRecommended ForHighlightsNext Steps
EmbraceBest Overall Pet Insurance Company
  • Tailored to your budget: Easily adjust your deductible, reimbursement rate, and annual limits (including an unlimited option) for coverage that fits your comfort level.
  • Coverage for curable pre-existing conditions: Unlike many competitors, conditions like past ear infections can become eligible for coverage if your pet is symptom-free for 12 months.
Check Rates
LemonadeBest for Online Experience
  • Claims Paid in Minutes: Around half of all claims are processed almost instantly by AI, with reimbursement hitting your account in 24–48 hours for simple cases.
  • Budget-Friendly Pricing: Plans start as low as $10 per month, making it one of the most affordable options for comprehensive pet coverage.
Check Rates
Pets BestBest for Value
  • Best-in-Class Affordability: Consistently ranked the cheapest major pet insurer for comprehensive accident and illness coverage.
  • Vet Direct Pay: The company pays your veterinarian directly during emergencies, eliminating the need to front thousands of dollars for reimbursement.
Check Rates
MetlifeBest for Multiple Pets
  • Financial Stability: Backed by MetLife with an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating.
  • Unique Family Plan: Covers up to three pets on one policy with a shared deductible.
Check Rates
PumpkinBest for Senior Pets
  • All-Inclusive Coverage: Get one plan that covers everything—dental illness, behavioral issues, hereditary conditions, and prescription food—with no sneaky add-on fees.
  • Rapid Care with PumpkinNow: Receive real-time payment for up to 90% of your eligible vet bill in minutes, often before you leave the clinic, for critical care claims over $1,000.
Check Rates
PrudentBest for Customer Support
  • 75% of claims processed in under 24 hours. Get your money back fast.
  • No age or breed restrictions. Perfect for senior pets and "high-risk" breeds.
Check Rates
ASPCABest for Customized Comprehensive Coverage
  • No Age Limit: Senior pets are welcome—enrollment has no upper age cap.
  • Comprehensive Coverage: Dental, behavioral, and alternative therapies are included in the base plan.
Check Rates
Healthy PawsBest for Young Dogs and Cats
  • Zero Payout Limits. Get true peace of mind with unlimited lifetime coverage—no cap on expensive surgeries or long-term illness costs.
  • 2-Day Claim Turnaround. Submit, approve, and get reimbursed faster than the industry average using the mobile app.
Check Rates

Top-Rated Pet Insurance Companies in Colorado of 2026

Embrace

Best Overall Pet Insurance Company
Editor's Rating
9.5
Great for Comprehensive Coverage

Embrace Pet Insurance is a highly recommended product primarily because of its flexibility and unique, comprehensive coverage options. Pet parents can highly customize their plan by choosing from various annual deductibles ($100 to $1,000), reimbursement percentages (70%, 80%, or 90%), and annual limits (from $5,000 up to unlimited), allowing them to perfectly balance budget and protection. A major differentiator is their policy on curable pre-existing conditions, which become eligible for coverage if the pet goes 12 months symptom-free. Furthermore, their standard accident and illness plan refreshingly includes dental illness coverage up to $1,000 per year for issues like gingivitis and extractions, a feature often excluded or an extra charge with competitors.

The company offers significant stability and valuable supplemental features that enhance the policy's value. Embrace is backed by an underwriter, American Modern Insurance Group, which holds an A+ (Superior) rating for financial strength from AM Best, suggesting high confidence in their ability to pay claims. The policy includes complimentary coverage for comprehensive alternative therapies, such as acupuncture and physical therapy, at no extra cost. Pet parents also benefit from the free, 24/7 PawSupport pet health line, which provides round-the-clock access to veterinary professionals for advice and peace of mind.

Ultimately, Embrace is a solid choice for long-term pet owners seeking peace of mind and excellent customization. The company has a strong track record, covering 92% of all claims in 2024 and paying out more than $212.5 million in claims that year, demonstrating financial reliability. While it sits in the middle of the pack price-wise, the value is clear, especially for owners of young pets or breeds prone to hereditary conditions. Their commitment to customization, combined with the coverage for curable pre-existing conditions and included dental illness care, makes it a powerful option for those who prioritize extensive coverage over finding the absolute lowest premium.

Embrace Pet Insurance at a Glance
  • Tailored to your budget: Easily adjust your deductible, reimbursement rate, and annual limits (including an unlimited option) for coverage that fits your comfort level.
  • Coverage for curable pre-existing conditions: Unlike many competitors, conditions like past ear infections can become eligible for coverage if your pet is symptom-free for 12 months.
  • Dental illness coverage included: Get up to $1,000 annually for dental issues, a feature often excluded or charged extra by others.
  • Comprehensive alternative therapies: Acupuncture, chiropractic care, and physical therapy are covered at no extra cost, supporting holistic treatment choices.
  • 24/7 Pet Health Helpline: Get peace of mind with around-the-clock access to veterinary professionals for urgent advice.

Lemonade Pet Insurance

Best for Online Experience
Editor's Rating
9.3
Great for Not Having to Speak to a Representative

Lemonade excels as a modern, technology-driven insurer, making it an excellent choice for pet owners who prefer a fully digital experience. Their highly-rated mobile app allows for simple account management, policy purchases, and claims filing. A major competitive advantage is their use of artificial intelligence in the claims process; this system is noted for its efficiency, approving approximately half of all claims instantly. This streamlined, rapid turnaround means money can hit a policyholder's bank account within a day or two for simple claims, providing real relief during stressful veterinary emergencies.

The product is highly competitive on price, regularly ranking among the most affordable options, with plans starting as low as $10 monthly. For budget-minded pet parents, Lemonade allows for significant customization to balance cost and coverage. Policyholders can build their ideal plan by selecting from multiple annual deductible amounts ($100 to $750), three reimbursement percentages (70%, 80%, or 90%), and a wide range of annual coverage caps, including high-end limits of up to $100,000. Furthermore, discounts are available for bundling with other Lemonade policies, paying annually, or insuring multiple pets.

Lemonade is structured as a certified B-Corporation and public benefit corporation, meaning they are legally required to weigh social impact alongside profit. This commitment manifests in their unique annual "Giveback" program, where remaining underwriting profits are donated to charities chosen by policyholders, channeling millions of dollars to non-profits annually. In terms of coverage, the base Accident & Illness plan is comprehensive, including diagnostic services, medication, and surgery. Importantly, it covers curable pre-existing conditions after a symptom-free year, and includes genetic and inherited conditions like hip dysplasia, which is vital for many purebred animals.

Lemonade Pet Insurance at a Glance
  • Claims Paid in Minutes: Around half of all claims are processed almost instantly by AI, with reimbursement hitting your account in 24–48 hours for simple cases.
  • Budget-Friendly Pricing: Plans start as low as $10 per month, making it one of the most affordable options for comprehensive pet coverage.
  • The Best Pet Insurance App: Rated 4.9 stars on the App Store, the intuitive mobile experience handles everything from quotes to claims filing smoothly.
  • Bundle & Save 10%: Get a discount on your pet insurance if you already have a Lemonade homeowners or renters policy.
  • Covers Inherited Conditions: Genetic and inherited conditions like hip dysplasia are covered, a critical feature for many breeds.

Pets Best Pet Insurance

Best for Value
Editor's Rating
9.3
Great for Affordibility Without Sacrificing Coverage

Pets Best consistently distinguishes itself in the pet insurance market by offering best-in-class affordability without compromising on comprehensive coverage. Their sample monthly premiums for dogs and cats are among the lowest of major pet insurers, providing a substantial financial benefit over the lifetime of a pet. This makes it an ideal option for budget-conscious owners who still require meaningful protection against accidents and illnesses, including hereditary and congenital conditions that are often excluded or costly with competitors. The ability to customize plans with flexible deductibles, reimbursement percentages, and annual limits further ensures that customers can tailor the policy to fit their specific budget and needs.

Beyond affordability, Pets Best offers unique features that significantly simplify the often-stressful claims process. The standout feature is Vet Direct Pay, which allows the company to pay the veterinarian directly for eligible claims. This eliminates the major financial burden of the pet parent having to front thousands of dollars in emergency situations and wait for reimbursement, making veterinary care more immediately accessible. Furthermore, the company is inclusive, welcoming senior pets with no upper age limits or coverage reductions, and offers a generous policy where curable pre-existing conditions can regain coverage if the pet remains symptom-free for 180 consecutive days.

Finally, Pets Best provides a solid foundation of reliable coverage backed by a company with nearly two decades of operating experience. Their BestBenefit Accident and Illness plans are genuinely comprehensive, covering everything from cancer treatment and chronic conditions to emergency surgery and prescription medications. The company is financially stable, being part of the broader IHC Group, which holds an A- (Excellent) financial strength rating. For pet parents seeking a balance of low premiums and robust, flexible coverage, Pets Best is a highly-rated option that delivers real value and peace of mind, especially with the Vet Direct Pay feature.

Pets Best Pet Insurance at a Glance
  • Best-in-Class Affordability: Consistently ranked the cheapest major pet insurer for comprehensive accident and illness coverage.
  • Vet Direct Pay: The company pays your veterinarian directly during emergencies, eliminating the need to front thousands of dollars for reimbursement.
  • Senior Pets Welcome: No upper age limits and no reduction in coverage just because your dog or cat is getting older.
  • Flexible Coverage: Choose your own deductible ($50 to $1,000), reimbursement percentage (70%, 80%, or 90%), and annual limit.
  • Curable Pre-Existing Conditions: Conditions that heal completely can become eligible for coverage again after 180 symptom-free days.

MetLife Pet Insurance

Best for Multiple Pets
Editor's Rating
9.3
Great for Shared Multi-Pet Deductibles

MetLife Pet Insurance is a strong choice primarily due to the exceptional financial backing of its parent company, MetLife Inc., which has an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating. This provides a significant layer of security and peace of mind, assuring policyholders that the insurer is stable and will be solvent to pay claims for years to come. Furthermore, the policies offer excellent flexibility regarding veterinary care, as they can be used at any licensed vet in the U.S., eliminating the need to worry about "in-network" providers.

The product stands out with several genuinely unique and appealing features, especially for specific pet-owner demographics. The signature "Family Plan," which covers up to three pets on a single policy with a shared deductible, is rare in the industry and can result in significant savings and simplified paperwork for multi-pet households. Additionally, MetLife has no upper age limit for enrollment, making it ideal for owners of senior pets who may be turned away by other insurers. The company also offers same-day accident coverage starting at midnight EST upon enrollment, and it is one of the few major insurers to cover exotic pets like birds, rabbits, ferrets, and reptiles in some states.

MetLife also offers comprehensive coverage that is highly customizable to fit various budgets and needs. The standard accident and illness plan is extensive, covering everything from emergency care and surgeries to prescription medications, chronic conditions, and even holistic therapies like acupuncture. Pet owners can fine-tune their plan with annual deductible options ranging from $0 to $2,500, reimbursement percentages up to 90%, and annual coverage limits that can go up to $25,000 or even unlimited. A range of discounts, including those for military, veterans, and multi-pet owners, further enhances the overall value proposition.

MetLife Pet Insurance at a Glance
  • Financial Stability: Backed by MetLife with an A+ (Superior) AM Best rating.
  • Unique Family Plan: Covers up to three pets on one policy with a shared deductible.
  • Same-Day Accident Coverage: Coverage begins at midnight following enrollment.
  • No Age Discrimination: Accepts pets of all ages, with no upper age limit for enrollment.
  • Flexible Customization: Highly customizable deductibles ($0-$2,500), reimbursement rates (50%-90%), and annual limits (up to unlimited).

Pumpkin Pet Insurance

Best for Older Pets
Editor's Rating
9.3
Great for Senior Pet Coverage

Pumpkin Pet Insurance stands out for its exceptional comprehensive coverage, designed to eliminate the confusion and surprise fees common in the industry. Their single, all-inclusive accident and illness plan covers a wide range of needs, including dental illnesses, behavioral issues, hereditary conditions, parasite infections, prescription food and supplements, and physical and alternative therapies all without requiring expensive add-ons. Furthermore, Pumpkin offers an industry-leading short 14-day waiting period for all eligible conditions, including traditionally long-wait orthopedic issues like hip dysplasia and knee injuries, ensuring pets can get covered and treated much faster than with most competitors.

The company earns its reputation as the best for senior pets by completely removing upper age restrictions and never reducing or limiting coverage as a pet ages, giving older dogs and cats the same great options as younger ones. In addition to being senior-friendly, Pumpkin is innovating the claims experience with its "PumpkinNow" feature. This special feature allows qualified customers to submit a claim and receive a real-time payment for up to 90% of the eligible veterinary bill in as fast as 15 minutes, often before they even leave the emergency clinic, which is a genuinely impactful benefit for critical care.

Finally, while the company is newer, it boasts a solid foundation and strong customer sentiment, which speaks to its reliability. It is financially backed by Zoetis and JAB Holding Company (a major pet insurance platform owner), and its policies are underwritten by United States Fire Insurance Company, which holds an A (Excellent) rating from AM Best. This financial strength is complemented by high customer satisfaction, with a 4.8/5 rating on Trustpilot and 4.5/5 on Google. Customers frequently praise the responsiveness of their customer service and the fairness and speed of the claims process.

Pumpkin Pet Insurance at a Glance
  • All-Inclusive Coverage: Get one plan that covers everything; dental illness, behavioral issues, hereditary conditions, and prescription food, with no sneaky add-on fees.
  • Rapid Care with PumpkinNow: Receive real-time payment for up to 90% of your eligible vet bill in minutes, often before you leave the clinic, for critical care claims over $1,000.
  • Shortest Waiting Period: Just 14 days for all accidents and illnesses, including orthopedic conditions like hip dysplasia and knee injuries that competitors make you wait six months for.
  • Best for Senior Pets: No upper age limits, no breed restrictions, and coverage that will never be reduced as your pet gets older.
  • Trusted and Highly Rated: Backed by major financial players and rated 4.8/5 on Trustpilot for rapid and fair claim processing.

Prudent Pet Insurance

Best for Customer Support
Editor's Rating
9.3
Great for Claims Process

Prudent Pet stands out primarily for its exceptional customer experience and lightning-fast claims processing. The company manages to process an impressive 75% of claims within 24 hours, a turnaround that is genuinely rare in the pet insurance industry where lengthy waits for reimbursement are common. This dedication to customer satisfaction is reflected in its stellar 4.9 out of 5 rating on Trustpilot, which ranks them first nationally for customer experience. Furthermore, every plan includes unlimited 24/7 access to licensed veterinarians via chat, providing pet owners with real-time advice that can potentially save an unnecessary emergency vet visit.

A key strength is the company’s inclusivity, as Prudent Pet maintains a policy of no age or breed restrictions. This makes it an ideal choice for owners of senior dogs and cats, or for those with breeds that other insurers commonly restrict or charge high premiums for due to hereditary issues (like brachycephalic breeds). The plans themselves are straightforward and customizable, a feature first-time pet insurance buyers appreciate, offering a clear path to comprehensive coverage that can be tailored with various deductible, reimbursement, and wellness options.

Finally, the company offers a strong sense of reliability and value. Although Prudent Pet is a newer company, its policies are underwritten by Markel Insurance Company, a specialty insurer with an A (Excellent) AM Best Financial Strength Rating, ensuring rock-solid financial backing. While their premiums are not the absolute cheapest on the market, their value proposition centers on time and sanity: the exceptional customer service, fast claims, and reliable financial standing make the slightly higher cost a worthwhile investment for pet parents who prioritize a hassle-free experience over pure price-shopping.

Prudent Pet Insurance at a Glance
  • 75% of claims processed in under 24 hours. Get your money back fast.
  • No age or breed restrictions. Perfect for senior pets and "high-risk" breeds.
  • Unlimited 24/7 Live Vet Chat included with every single plan.
  • Rated 4.9/5 stars on Trustpilot. Exceptional customer satisfaction.
  • Backed by Markel Insurance with an A (Excellent) financial strength rating.

ASPCA Pet Insurance

Best for Customizable Comprehensive Coverage
Editor's Rating
9.0
Great for Personalized Coverage

ASPCA Pet Health Insurance stands out for its genuinely comprehensive base plan and its inclusive policy on senior pets. Unlike many competitors that charge extra, ASPCA's Complete Coverage plan automatically includes important treatments like dental disease, hereditary conditions, alternative therapies (such as acupuncture and hydrotherapy), and behavioral treatments. This broad inclusion simplifies the coverage and ensures that pet parents are protected against a wider range of unexpected health issues from the start. Crucially, there is no upper age limit for enrollment, making it one of the best options on the market for senior pets whose financial safety net is often restricted elsewhere.

The policy terms also present favorable aspects for pet owners. The multi-pet discount, offering 10% off each additional pet, stacks nicely for larger "fur families" and can lead to significant annual savings. For breeds prone to common joint issues, the waiting period for orthopedic issues is only 14 days, which is much shorter than the typical six to twelve months required by many other insurers. Furthermore, a curable pre-existing condition that remains symptom-free and treatment-free for 180 days can become eligible for coverage again, offering a valuable path back to protection for many pets (with the exception of knee and ligament issues).

Finally, the insurer offers reassuring company stability and valuable special features. The policies are underwritten by United States Fire Insurance Company, which holds an A (Excellent) financial strength rating from A.M. Best. This financial muscle, combined with a low complaint index of just 0.3 (well below the industry average of 1.0), suggests high reliability for claim payouts. Every policy also includes 24/7 access to The Vet Connection telehealth service, allowing pet parents to get expert advice from real vets and vet nurses around the clock, which can be an immense source of peace of mind during a stressful emergency.

ASPCA Pet Insurance at a Glance
  • No Age Limit: Senior pets are welcome. Enrollment has no upper age cap.
  • Comprehensive Coverage: Dental, behavioral, and alternative therapies are included in the base plan.
  • 10% Multi-Pet Discount: Perfect for households with more than one fur baby.
  • 24/7 Vet Helpline: Peace of mind with round-the-clock access to real vet professionals.
  • Fast Ortho Coverage: Only a 14-day waiting period for orthopedic conditions.

Healthy Paws Pet Insurance

Best for Young Dogs and Cats
Editor's Rating
9.0
Great for Puppies

Healthy Paws is an excellent fit for a specific type of pet owner: primarily those with a young or middle-aged pet (under six years old) whose main goal is protection against catastrophic, high-cost veterinary events. This plan is designed for the owner who wants the ultimate safety net, offering a genuinely rare unlimited payout structure that ensures expensive procedures, like a $30,000 surgery or ongoing cancer treatments, will not hit an annual or lifetime coverage ceiling.

The plan's key strength is its appealing simplicity. It offers exactly one plan covering accidents and illnesses, which is ideal for people who view insurance shopping as a chore and prefer to minimize time spent comparing endless coverage tiers, wellness riders, and confusing policy details. This straightforward approach, combined with a quick, app-based claims process that is often praised by customers, makes the experience streamlined and easy to manage without the hassle of paperwork or long waiting times for reimbursement.

Finally, Healthy Paws is perfect for those who value rock-solid financial stability and a straightforward, no-fuss approach. Backed by the global insurance giant Chubb, with its A++ rating from AM Best, customers don't have to worry about the company's ability to pay out massive claims years down the line. While it lacks discounts and wellness options, the value proposition is strongest for the owner prioritizing peace of mind against the worst-case scenario over coverage optimization and routine maintenance benefits.

Healthy Paws Pet Insurance at a Glance
  • Zero Payout Limits. Get true peace of mind with unlimited lifetime coverage. No cap on expensive surgeries or long-term illness costs.
  • 2-Day Claim Turnaround. Submit, approve, and get reimbursed faster than the industry average using the mobile app.
  • Paperless Claims. Skip the forms and simply photograph your vet bill to file a claim in minutes.
  • Broad Coverage. Includes therapies many competitors charge extra for, such as acupuncture and physical therapy.
  • A++ Financial Security. Backed by Chubb, a global insurer with the highest financial rating, ensuring your claims will be paid.

Why Colorado Pet Owners Need Insurance

Colorado’s unique geography creates pet health challenges unlike anywhere else in the country. The state’s high altitude, which defines life along the Front Range and in the mountains, can cause altitude sickness in pets and make breathing harder for brachycephalic breeds. Colorado tick fever is a tick-borne illness found almost exclusively in the Rocky Mountain region. Mountain lions pose a genuine threat to pets in foothill communities. And the extreme outdoor lifestyle that draws people to Colorado means dogs face more environmental exposure than in most states. Meanwhile, Denver’s booming economy has driven veterinary costs significantly higher, with the Front Range now rivaling coastal cities for many procedures.

Veterinary costs in Colorado have risen substantially as the state’s population has grown. The Denver metro area, including Boulder, Fort Collins, and Colorado Springs, has costs well above national averages. Routine office visits in Denver run $85 to $160, and emergency triage starts at $300 to $475. Boulder is often even higher than its affluent population would suggest. The mountain communities like Vail, Aspen, and Breckenridge have limited veterinary options with premium pricing. The Eastern Plains and Western Slope are more affordable, with office visits typically $55 to $95. Across the state, serious emergencies usually run $3,000 to $7,000, with Denver specialty hospitals reaching $8,000 to $12,000 or more for complex cases.

Colorado has approximately 1.4 million pet dogs and 1.3 million pet cats. The state’s outdoor culture is extraordinary; Colorado consistently ranks among the most active states in the nation, and dogs are an integral part of that lifestyle. Hiking, camping, skiing, and outdoor adventure are central to Colorado living, and dogs join their owners on trails from the plains to the peaks. This active lifestyle, while wonderful for pets, increases exposure to Colorado’s environmental hazards significantly compared to states where dogs spend more time indoors.

Colorado-Specific Risks to Consider

Colorado’s environment presents unique hazards, making pet insurance particularly valuable.

High altitude effects are a distinctive Colorado concern that affects pets just as it affects humans. Denver sits at 5,280 feet, and much of the Front Range is at similar or higher elevations. Mountain communities are significantly higher; Breckenridge is at 9,600 feet, Leadville at 10,200 feet. Dogs can experience altitude sickness when traveling to high elevations, with symptoms including lethargy, vomiting, difficulty breathing, and in severe cases, life-threatening pulmonary or cerebral edema. Flat-faced breeds (bulldogs, pugs, French bulldogs, Boston terriers) are at particular risk because they already have compromised breathing. Even well-conditioned dogs can struggle at elevation, especially during vigorous activity. Pet owners who take their dogs to the mountains for hiking or skiing need to be aware of altitude-related risks. Treatment for severe altitude sickness can cost $1,500 to $4,000 or more.

Colorado tick fever is a tick-borne viral disease found almost exclusively in the Rocky Mountain region, making it a uniquely Colorado concern. The disease is transmitted by the Rocky Mountain wood tick, which is common in Colorado’s mountains and foothills at elevations between 4,000 and 10,000 feet. Colorado tick fever causes fever, lethargy, and muscle pain, and can lead to serious complications. While most cases resolve with supportive care, severe cases can require hospitalization. This disease is distinct from Rocky Mountain spotted fever and Lyme disease, which are also present in Colorado, though less common than in eastern states. Dogs that hike in the mountains during tick season (March through September) face an increased risk of exposure to ticks.

Mountain lions (cougars) are a genuine threat to pets in Colorado. The state has a substantial mountain lion population, estimated at 3,000 to 7,000 animals, and encounters with pets occur regularly in foothill communities along the Front Range. Communities from Fort Collins to Colorado Springs that border open space report mountain lion sightings and attacks. Dogs are particularly vulnerable because they can appear as prey or as threats to cubs. Attacks can be fatal or cause severe injuries requiring extensive emergency surgery. Mountain lion encounters are more common in Colorado than in most other states due to the interface between suburban development and lion habitat. While these attacks aren’t everyday occurrences, they happen often enough that Front Range pet owners should be aware of the risk.

Black bears are found throughout Colorado’s mountains and increasingly in foothill communities. Bear-dog encounters typically occur when dogs surprise bears or when dogs are perceived as threats to cubs. These encounters can result in serious injuries. Bears are most active from spring through fall, and conflicts increase in years with poor natural food crops when bears venture into residential areas. Mountain communities and Front Range neighborhoods adjacent to open space have the highest encounter rates.

Rattlesnakes are found throughout Colorado, particularly on the Eastern Plains and in the foothills. The prairie rattlesnake is the most common species, found from the plains up to about 9,500 feet. The Western massasauga and midget faded rattlesnake are also present in parts of the state. Snake encounters are every day during warm months, especially on hiking trails at lower elevations. Rattlesnake bites require immediate veterinary attention and often antivenom treatment. Costs typically run $2,000 to $5,000 or more, depending on the severity of envenomation. Rattlesnake aversion training is popular in Colorado for good reason.

Plague exists in Colorado’s prairie dog populations and can be transmitted to pets. Yes, actual plague, the same disease that caused the Black Death, is endemic in rodent populations throughout the Western United States, with Colorado being a hotspot. Dogs and cats can contract plague from infected rodents or their fleas. While rare, pet plague cases occur in Colorado each year. The disease is treatable with antibiotics if caught early, but it can be fatal if delayed. Pets that have contact with prairie dogs, ground squirrels, or their burrows are at risk. This is a uniquely Western concern that Colorado pet owners should be aware of.

Leptospirosis is present in Colorado’s mountain streams, lakes, and standing water. The bacteria spread through contaminated water and the urine of infected wildlife. Dogs that drink from streams, ponds, or puddles while hiking can be exposed. The disease causes kidney and liver failure and can be fatal. Colorado’s outdoor lifestyle means many dogs drink from natural water sources, increasing exposure risk. Treatment typically costs $2,000 to $5,500 for hospitalization and supportive care.

Giardia is ubiquitous in Colorado’s mountain streams. This intestinal parasite is found even in pristine-looking mountain water and is spread by wildlife. Dogs that drink from streams while hiking frequently contract Giardia. While usually not life-threatening, Giardia causes significant gastrointestinal distress and requires treatment. Repeated infections are common for dogs who regularly drink from natural water sources.

Extreme weather variability is a defining characteristic of Colorado. The state is famous for dramatic weather swings, with temperatures sometimes changing 40 to 50 degrees in a single day. Sudden snowstorms can occur even in late spring or early fall, catching hikers and their dogs unprepared. Afternoon thunderstorms are common in the mountains during summer, and lightning poses a real risk at elevation. This weather unpredictability means pets can face hypothermia, heat stroke, and storm-related emergencies with little warning.

Coyotes are abundant throughout Colorado, including in Denver, Boulder, Fort Collins, and other urban areas. Coyote attacks on small pets are common, occurring in suburban backyards and even in urban neighborhoods. Colorado’s coyotes are bold and have adapted well to urban environments. Small dogs and outdoor cats are at significant risk.

Foxtails and grass awns are a significant concern on Colorado’s Eastern Plains and in grassland areas. These barbed seed heads can embed in a dog’s skin, ears, nose, eyes, or paws, and migrate through tissue, causing serious infections and damage. They’re particularly common in late summer when grasses dry out. Removal often requires sedation, and complications from embedded foxtails can cost $500 to $2,500 or more to treat.

Orthopedic injuries from outdoor activities are more common in Colorado than in most states due to the active lifestyle. Dogs who hike rugged terrain, run on mountain trails, or engage in winter activities face elevated risks of ACL tears, fractures, and other orthopedic injuries. The combination of rough terrain and high-activity dogs means Colorado veterinarians see plenty of sports injuries. ACL surgery alone costs $3,500 to $6,000 in the Denver area.

Wildfire smoke has become an increasing concern in Colorado during fire season. Smoke from both local and regional wildfires can affect air quality for extended periods, and pets with respiratory conditions are particularly vulnerable. Severe smoke exposure can cause respiratory distress requiring veterinary attention.

The Colorado Cost Reality

Here’s what standard procedures actually cost in Colorado compared to national averages:

Routine care:

Annual exam: $85 to $160 in Denver/Boulder, $55 to $95 elsewhere

Dental cleaning: $500 to $1,000 in Denver/Boulder, $350 to $700 elsewhere

Spay/neuter: $350 to $650 in Denver/Boulder, $200 to $400 elsewhere

Emergency and specialty care:

Emergency room visit: $300 to $475 for triage in Denver/Boulder, $175 to $300 elsewhere

Rattlesnake bite treatment: $2,000 to $5,000 in CO

Colorado tick fever treatment: $500 to $2,500, depending on severity

Altitude sickness treatment: $1,500 to $4,000 in CO

Leptospirosis treatment: $2,000 to $5,500 in CO

Foxtail removal (complicated): $500 to $2,500 in CO

ACL surgery: $4,000 to $6,000 in Denver/Boulder, $3,000 to $4,500 elsewhere

Cancer treatment: $7,000 to $15,000+ in Denver/Boulder, $5,000 to $10,000 elsewhere

Colorado’s veterinary costs have risen significantly with the state’s population growth, particularly along the Front Range; Denver and Boulder now rival coastal cities for many procedures. Combined with Colorado’s unique environmental hazards and the high-activity lifestyle that increases injury risk, insurance provides essential financial protection for Colorado pet owners.

Who Should Get Pet Insurance in Colorado

Pet insurance makes particular sense for Colorado residents in these situations.

You hike, camp, or go on adventures with your dog. Colorado’s outdoor lifestyle is fantastic for dogs, but it comes with exposure to rattlesnakes, ticks, wildlife, leptospirosis, Giardia, and orthopedic injury risk. If you and your dog regularly go out on trails, comprehensive coverage is essential.

You live along the Front Range. Communities from Fort Collins to Colorado Springs that border open space face risks from mountain lions, bears, and coyotes. These foothill areas also have significant tick activity and rattlesnake presence. If you’re in these Front Range communities, environmental risks are elevated.

You live in or frequently visit mountain communities. High altitude affects pets, and mountain communities have limited access to veterinary care. Emergency care may require transport to Denver. If you ski, have a mountain cabin, or live at elevation, insurance provides essential protection.

You live in the Denver or Boulder metro areas. These areas have the highest veterinary costs in Colorado, rivaling coastal cities. If you’re paying Front Range prices, insurance is essential financial protection against expensive emergencies.

You have a flat-faced breed. Brachycephalic dogs face serious challenges at high elevations in Colorado. Even in Denver at 5,280 feet, flat-faced breeds have to work harder to breathe. Taking these dogs to the mountains significantly increases risk. If you have a bulldog, pug, French bulldog, or similar breed in Colorado, insurance is critical.

Your dog is highly active or athletic. Colorado’s terrain and active lifestyle mean more orthopedic injuries. Dogs who run trails, hike fourteeners, or engage in dog sports face elevated injury risk. If your dog is your adventure partner, coverage for orthopedic injuries is essential.

You have a small dog or outdoor cat. Coyotes are abundant throughout Colorado, including in Denver and Boulder. Mountain lions can also prey on small pets in foothill areas. If you have a small pet with any outdoor access, predator encounters are a genuine concern.

You live on or near the Eastern Plains. This region has rattlesnakes, foxtails, and plague-carrying prairie dogs. While vet costs are lower, the environmental hazards are real.

Colorado Pet Insurance Considerations

When shopping for pet insurance as a Colorado resident, keep these factors in mind.

Premiums vary significantly by region. Denver and Boulder ZIP codes will have the highest premiums in the state, often 20% to 35% higher than those on the Western Slope or the Eastern Plains. This reflects the real cost of veterinary care in different areas.

All major pet insurers operate in Colorado. The state’s substantial and growing population means every major provider is available. Denver’s competitive market offers a range of good options.

Verify tick-borne illness coverage. Colorado tick fever is unique to this region. Confirm that this disease, along with Rocky Mountain spotted fever and Lyme disease, is covered under illness benefits.

Check rattlesnake bite coverage. Confirm that venomous snake bites are covered under accident benefits and that antivenom treatment is included. This is a typical Colorado emergency.

Ensure wildlife encounter coverage. Verify that injuries from mountain lions, bears, and coyotes are covered. Given Colorado’s wildlife interface, this coverage matters.

Consider orthopedic coverage carefully. Colorado’s active lifestyle means higher orthopedic injury rates. Some policies have waiting periods for orthopedic conditions or exclude bilateral conditions. Review these provisions carefully.

The Key Features That Matter for Colorado Pet Owners
An annual maximum of at least $10,000 is recommended for Colorado pet owners, given the rising costs along the Front Range. Denver and Boulder residents should consider $10,000 to $15,000 or unlimited coverage. Active dogs with high outdoor exposure should also have higher limits.

Accident coverage is critical in Colorado, given the risks from rattlesnakes, wildlife, and orthopedic injuries from outdoor activities. Look for policies that offer accident coverage within a few days of enrollment.

Illness coverage should include tick-borne diseases (especially Colorado tick fever), leptospirosis, Giardia, and altitude-related conditions. Make sure waiting periods are reasonable (14 days is standard). AnA 80% reimbursement rate is recommended for Denver and Boulder residents, given the high costs. A $6,000 ACL surgery at 70% reimbursement leaves you paying $1,800 out of pocket; at 80%, it’s $1,200.

24/7 vet helpline access is particularly valuable in Colorado, where you may be hours from emergency care while hiking or in mountain communities. Expert guidance can help you decide when to evacuate.

How to Choose Pet Insurance in Colorado

Step 1: Get quotes from at least three insurers. Enter your actual Colorado ZIP code to get accurate regional pricing. A Denver or Boulder quote will be significantly different from a Grand Junction or the Eastern Plains.

Step 2: Verify coverage for Colorado-specific hazards. Confirm that Colorado tick fever, rattlesnake bites, altitude-related illness, and wildlife encounters are all covered.

Step 3: Review orthopedic coverage carefully. Check waiting periods for ACL and other orthopedic injuries. Some policies have waiting periods of 6 to 12 months for these conditions.

Step 4: Consider your specific lifestyle. If you’re very active outdoors, prioritize accident coverage and higher limits. If you live at an altitude where flat-faced breeds are common, ensure your illness coverage is comprehensive.

Step 5: Factor in mountain access. If you frequently visit areas far from emergency care, a 24/7 helpline becomes more valuable. Consider whether you’ll need to transport your pet in case of an emergency.

Step 6: Check for bundling opportunities. If you have renters’ or homeowners insurance with a provider that offers pet coverage, bundling may save you money.

The Bottom Line for Colorado Pet Parents

Pet insurance in Colorado is about managing the unique combination of high-altitude living, dramatic wildlife, and an outdoor lifestyle that puts dogs in harm’s way more often than in most states. Colorado tick fever is found almost nowhere else. Mountain lions are a real threat along the Front Range. Rattlesnakes are common at lower elevations. And the active outdoor lifestyle that defines Colorado living means more orthopedic injuries and environmental exposures than the typical indoor pet faces.

The best time to enroll is when your pet is young and healthy, before any snake bites, orthopedic injuries, or tick exposures create pre-existing conditions. Colorado’s outdoor hazards are year-round concerns, so early enrollment provides essential protection. The state’s rising veterinary costs, particularly along the Front Range, make insurance increasingly valuable.

Choose a policy with strong accident coverage for Colorado’s environmental hazards, comprehensive illness coverage including tick-borne diseases, and appropriate limits for your region’s costs. Then enjoy everything the Centennial State has to offer with your four-legged companion, from the fourteeners to the plains to the vibrant neighborhoods of Denver and beyond, knowing you’re prepared for whatever Colorado throws your way.

How Pet Insurance Providers Stacked Up

Our experts scored and compared pet insurance providers to bring you the definitive rankings.

Pet Insurance CompanyStabilityCoverageAffordabiliutyClaimsCustomer ServiceRaw ScoreCurved Score
Embrace987877.79.5
Metlife97.577.577.559.3
Lemonade778877.59.3
Pets Best789767.59.3
Pumpkin88697.57.59.3
Prudent876897.59.3
ASPCA987677.39
Healthy Paws976877.39
Spot886877.28.9
AKC777787.28.9
Trupanion885977.18.8
Fetch896777.18.8

Geico (Powered by Embrace)

987877.79.5
Hartville9776678.6
Many Pets787766.98.5
Figo876766.78.3
Liberty Mutual Pet Insurance877656.68.1
PetPremium876566.37.8
Banfield856645.97.3
Nationwide765565.77
author avatar
Michael Wagner Editor
Driven by a lifelong mission to master his personal finances, Michael Wagner is a seasoned personal finance writer with 10 years of expertise covering retirement plans and insurance. Growing up in a lower-middle-class household, Michael became obsessed with finance upon graduating from college. His passion is rooted in sharing that hard-earned knowledge. As a former licensed insurance agent, he brings a practical, licensed perspective to his content, helping readers answer their most pressing questions and ultimately improve their financial standing.

Important Information About Pet Insurance

*Insurance needs vary significantly based on individual circumstances. This page provides general information and should not be considered personal insurance advice. Always read policy documents carefully and consider consulting with a licensed insurance professional for guidance on your specific situation.

**Company information and offerings may have changed since the time of writing. Please always verify the current details before purchasing an individual policy.  Data has been compiled from the company’s official website, NAIC complaint data, J.D. Power studies, AM Best ratings, and other first-party sources. Rates and product availability may vary by state. Always confirm current pricing and features with an advisor before making a purchase decision.